Anal pre-cancer (anal intraepithelial neoplasia)
What is anal pre-cancer?
The term “anal pre-cancer” is used to describe conditions which, in a small minority of people, can progress to cancer. The rate of progression from pre-cancer to cancer is not known, but may be of the order of 1 in 4000 per year for HIV negative people and 1 in 400 per year for those with HIV.
The term “High grade Squamous Intraepithelial Lesions (HSIL)” is used to describe the microscopic appearances of pre-cancer. Sometimes HSIL is divided into two forms, called Anal Intraepithelial Neoplasia (AIN), grades 2 and 3. Grade 3 is regarded as more serious than grade 2. Many AIN1 lesions are entirely benign and never progress.
Where does HSIL occur?
Anal HSIL may be described according to where it is found:
- Perianal – when it develops just outside the anus, within 5cm of the edge of the anus
- Intra-anal – when it occurs inside the anus, mostly within the first 5cm inside the anus
It is possible to have anal HSIL in both sites at the same time.
What does anal HSIL mean for HIV-negative gay men?
Around 20% of HIV-negative gay or bisexual men have anal HSIL. Most people are likely to be unaware they have the condition, unless they have special tests performed on the anus It has been estimated that around 1 in 4000 such men will progress to cancer each year.
What does anal HSIL mean for HIV-positive gay men?
Around 30% of HIV-positive gay or bisexual men have anal HSIL. Most people are likely to be unaware they have the condition, unless they have special tests performed on the anus It has been estimated that around 1 in 400 such men will progress to cancer each year.
What does anal HSIL mean for women?
A small, unknown, proportion of women develops anal HSIL. It is approximately 10 times more common in women who have a history of HPV-related abnormalities in the cervix, vagina or vulva.
HIV-positive women are also at higher risk. It is important that all HIV-positive women have regularly cervical Pap smears.
Who else is at risk of HSIL?
Cigarette smokers have increased risk of developing anal cancer. Stopping smoking is important for all people, particularly those diagnosed with HSIL or anal cancer.
People with problems of their immune systems may be at increased risk of anal cancer. This includes people who have had an organ transplant or conditions like systemic lupus.
What are the symptoms of anal HSIL?
Most people who have anal HSIL have no symptoms and don't know they have it. If symptoms do occur, they include discolouration of the skin, itch, pain, lumpy skin or bleeding.
What causes anal HSIL?
Anal HSIL may occur following infection with certain “high risk” HPV types, especially type 16. Anal warts are more typically due to different types of HPV (“low risk”) types – these are most commonly types 6 and 11.
What is Human Papilloma Virus (HPV)?
HPV is the most common sexually transmitted infection in the world. Anogenital HPV infection is divided into two groups:
“High risk” types, of which HPV type 16 is the most common. Other high risk types include types 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 68, 73, and 82.
“Low risk” types, of which HPV type 6 is the most common. These are most often associated with benign anogenital warts. Other low risk anogenital HPV types include HPV 11, 42, 43, and 44.
How common is HPV and what are the symptoms?
Because infection is so common, most people encounter HPV very early on in their sexual careers. The majority of people infected with HPV have no symptoms or signs and their immune systems successfully get rid of it, without the person ever being aware that it has happened. However, in a minority of people, the infection persists. A minority of those with persisting HPV infection can then go on to develop symptoms or HSIL.
Warts typically appear as single or multiple soft, moist, or flesh-coloured bumps in the ano-genital areas. They sometimes appear in clusters that resemble cauliflower-like bumps, and may be raised or flat, small or large. Simple warts are essentially a cosmetic problem and are not generally regarded as pre-cancerous.
How is HPV transmitted?
HPV is very infectious and is spread by skin-to-skin contact during oral, vaginal, or anal sex with an infected partner. It can also be spread by non-penetrative sex, such as touching with hands. Recent evidence suggests that it can be spread from the vaginal region to the anus in women by wiping. This suggests that women should generally wipe “from back to front”, rather than “from front to back”, to avoid transmitting HPV to the anal region.
How can transmission be prevented?
The only way to prevent getting an HPV infection is to avoid direct skin-to-skin contact with an infected person. Using condoms may partially reduce your risk of HPV. However, condoms do provide excellent protection against other sexually transmitted infections, including HIV.
Should I get vaccinated?
The currently available vaccines are Gardasil, Cervarix and Gardasil 9. They all can provide protection against high risk HPV types 16 and 18, but vary in the other HPV types that they additionally cover.
All of the above vaccines can protect people against acquiring HPV, but must be given before initial exposure to the particular HPV type. As most people encounter HPV soon after becoming sexually active, this means that the vaccines should be given as early as possible. This is why schools-based vaccination programs are the most effective.
Current evidence suggests that they are likely to work in men under the age of 26 years and women under the age of 45. It is not known whether it is worthwhile getting vaccinated if people are older.
How is HPV treated?
Currently there is no known cure for HPV infection.
Genital warts sometimes disappear without treatment, but there is no way to predict whether warts will grow or disappear. There are several creams and solutions available for their treatment, depending on their size and location. Some lesions may also be treated by freezing, burning or laser treatment. Although these treatments remove the warts, they do not necessarily remove the virus. Thus, as HPV may still be present after such treatment, and warts often come back.
People who smoke cigarettes may respond less well to treatment.
Can I get tested for HPV infection?
There are number of tests now available that will detect the presence of HPV infection. Testing for high risk HPV infection is increasingly done as part of cervical screening procedures, and to monitor response to treatment. Their role in the diagnosis and management of anal conditions is currently under evaluation.
What tests can be done to diagnose anal HSIL?
- Inspection: Close examination of the external anal area by a specialist can sometimes suggest a diagnosis of HSIL. However, changes can often be very subtle and easily missed. Internal anal HSIL can rarely be diagnosed by looking at the area, even when using an instrument such as a proctoscope.
- Anal Papanicolaou (“Pap”) smears
- High Resolution Anoscopy (HRA)
- Biopsies: These may be taken from the outside of the anus (perianal biopsy) or internally.
How is anal HSIL treated?
A large majority of people with HSIL never develop cancer. However, all HSIL cases must be taken seriously and it is important to discuss matters carefully with your doctor, to see what options are best for you.
There is currently a large trial being conducted in the United States (the ANCHOR Trial) that has been specifically set up to determine what the best treatment approach is. It is due to report in the year 2022. Until then, the evidence supporting different treatments is not strong. These include:
- No treatment. This is based on the observation that the vast majority of anal HSIL never progress to cancer. However, close observation is necessary, to ensure that any changes are detected early
- Surgery. This is reserved for the larger lesions that have features suggesting they are likely to progress. Whilst the treatment removes the lesion, surgery may cause damaging scarring and recurrences can occur
- Other physically ablative methods. This includes electrocautery, infra-red coagulation and laser. These are less likely to cause long term problems than surgery, but require repeated treatments using High Resolution Anoscopy. Recurrences are common.
- Application of creams such as imiquimod and podophyllotoxin. These are most commonly used for perianal lesions, as they can cause significant burning. Recurrences are common.
Your specialist will be the best person to discuss which approach is the most appropriate for you. Although likely, there is currently no hard evidence that any of these treatments reduce the risk of development of anal cancer.
What should I do if I am worried about anal HSIL?
Talk things over with your doctor, who will perform an initial assessment. If necessary, then you can be referred to a specialised service. If you are uncomfortable about talking over such matters with your doctor, Sexual Health Clinics often offer very useful advice.
More information is available at a number of sites, including: